
By: Dr Hafez Mohamed Farid Hamed
School of Business
International Academy of Engineering and Media Science, Egypt
hafez.mohammed.farid@iaems.edu.eg
A junior analyst presents a report to her manager. The numbers are right, but the structure confuses the room, and the meeting runs over. That night she is tempted to think: “I am not good at this job.” (This is a hypothetical example.)
Suppose she does. That thought would move from one presentation to her whole ability, and a short step further could take it to her value as a person. Nothing in the meeting supports that jump. What the evidence supports is narrower: the report was accurate and the structure was unclear.
This confusion between performance and worth makes self-review painful and, often, useless. If every weakness feels like a verdict, you will either avoid looking at it or punish yourself and learn little. A better approach is the one a good manager uses with a team member: precise, fair and focused on what to change.
Why self-blame does not help
Self-criticism can feel like discipline. It may even feel responsible. But harsh self-judgment can make it harder to look closely at what went wrong, because looking closely becomes uncomfortable. You may start to avoid the very tasks you want to improve.
This does not mean you should lower your standards. High standards and fairness can sit together. A manager can expect a lot from a person and still describe a mistake without insulting them. You can do the same for yourself.
Separate three levels
When something goes badly, ask which level you are talking about.
The event: what actually happened. “The presentation ran fifteen minutes over and two people asked me to repeat the main point.”
The performance: what part of your work contributed. “I put the conclusion on the last slide and spent too long on method.”
The person: your worth. Nothing in a single event settles this.
Most useful review stays on the first two levels. Write the event as a fact, as if you were describing it to someone who was not there. Then identify what you controlled and what you did not.
A review you can repeat
Here is a simple structure for a fortnightly or monthly self-review. It takes thirty minutes.
- What did I intend to achieve? Write two or three goals from the period.
- What actually happened? Facts and results, with dates and numbers where you honestly have them.
- What helped, and what got in the way? Include things outside your control, such as unclear instructions or changes in priorities.
- What is one thing I will do differently? One, not ten.
- What did I do well? Be specific. This is not flattery. It tells you what to keep doing.
Notice that question five is there for accuracy. If you only record failures, your record is incomplete, and incomplete evidence leads to poor decisions.
Be fair about causes
When results are poor, it is tempting to blame yourself entirely or to blame everyone else. Both are shortcuts. Try to list possible causes and weigh them.
In the analyst’s case, possible causes include her slide structure, the time she was given, the audience’s expectations, her own preparation and the lack of a rehearsal. Some are within her control. A rehearsal with a colleague would be one realistic fix. Complaining that the audience was impatient would not help her, even if it were partly true.
The aim is not to find the perfect explanation. It is to choose one or two causes that you can act on and test.
For founders
A founder has an extra difficulty: the business and the person feel like one thing. If sales fall, it is easy to feel personally defeated.
Separate the founder from the venture in the same way. Review the business as you would review a client’s: customers won, customers lost, margin, cash, delivery times. Then ask what the numbers suggest, and which assumption you want to test next.
For example, a small online service may lose customers after the first month. The founder may decide she is bad at selling. But the data might show that customers leave after a delayed delivery. That is a process problem, not a personal one. (Hypothetical, but a realistic pattern to check.)
Feedback and your review
Your own review has blind spots. Ask one or two people you trust for a specific observation about one piece of work. Choose people who have seen it. Ask for something you can act on, such as “What would have made the structure clearer?” Compare what they say with your own notes. If a point appears in both, it deserves attention. If only one person says it, consider it, but do not treat it as settled.
Be clear with yourself about the difference between a useful comment and a general opinion. A comment such as “you rush the ending” gives you something to practise. A comment such as “you are not a natural” does not.
A short exercise
Think of one recent piece of work that did not go well.
- Write what happened in three factual sentences, with no adjectives about yourself.
- List two things you did that contributed and one thing outside your control.
- Write one action for next time and when you will do it.
- Write one thing you did well in the same piece of work.
Then close the page. The point is a clear next step, not a longer discussion with yourself.
The decision
Choose a regular time for a short review, for example the last Friday of each month. Use the five questions above. At the end, write one sentence beginning “Next month I will…” that someone else could check. Review the performance carefully, and leave your worth out of the calculation.
#CMA #Careers #hafezfarid #cmafasttrack
