
By: Dr Hafez Mohamed Farid Hamed
School of Business
International Academy of Engineering and Media Science, Egypt
hafez.mohammed.farid@iaems.edu.eg
A recent graduate sends twenty applications and receives two interview invitations. She decides her problem is confidence and signs up for a course. She may be right. But at this point she has an assumption, not a finding. (This is a hypothetical example, not a real case.)
An assumption is not a diagnosis
Much self-development begins with a belief about ourselves: “I am not confident enough”, “I am bad at time management”, “I need more knowledge.” The belief may be correct. It may also be a convenient explanation that hides the real obstacle.
In HR, we try not to design training before we understand the performance gap. The same discipline applies to you. Before you spend money or months on development, ask what the gap actually is and what is causing it.
In our example, the graduate reviews her applications. Her CV lists duties but shows no results. Employers cannot see what she achieved. The gap may be in how she presents her work, not in her confidence. A confidence course could still be useful. It just may not be the first thing to try.
Test the belief before you act on it
Three questions help. Write the answers down.
- What evidence do I have? Separate facts from feelings. Twenty applications and two interviews is a fact, though it needs context, such as the type of roles and the state of the job market. “I feel I am not good enough” tells you how you feel. It does not prove why the results are low.
- What else could explain it? List at least two other causes. Is it knowledge, skill, habit, or something in your environment, such as an unclear role or a weak offer?
- What would change my mind? Decide in advance what result would show your first belief was wrong.
Knowledge, skill, habit and environment are a practical way to sort possible causes. They are a working tool, not a proven model, and real problems often mix more than one.
What counts as useful evidence
Evidence always needs context. Different kinds of information answer different questions.
- Outcomes you can count, such as interviews, replies, repeat customers or deadlines met. They show what happened, but not always why. Two interviews from twenty applications means more if you know the type of roles and how competitive they are.
- Feelings and impressions. They are real evidence of your experience, for example that you felt anxious in an interview. They are not proof of the cause of the result.
- Comments from others. Specific comments from people who have seen your work are valuable, but they can also be biased or based on limited information, so compare more than one view.
- Things you have not tried yet. If you have never asked for feedback on your CV, you do not know whether it is the problem.
No single source settles the question. When your evidence is thin, your first task is to collect more before committing months to a programme.
Ask for feedback you may not enjoy
Your own view is only one source. Ask two or three people who have seen your work. Be specific: “Which part of my CV would make you trust me more? Which part would make you hesitate?” A specific question gives people something concrete to respond to.
Then listen without defending yourself. Good feedback is precise and about the work, not about your worth. If someone says your presentation lacks structure, that is a task. It is not a verdict on you.
Be demanding with yourself in the same way. Do not accept “I will try harder” as a plan. Ask: what exactly will I do differently, and how will I know it worked?
For entrepreneurs: test the idea, not only yourself
Imagine a founder who has launched a small online service and has few customers. She decides she needs to learn marketing. Perhaps. But there are other questions to test first. Does the customer have the problem she thinks they have? Will they pay the price she charges? Does the cost of serving them leave a margin? Can she deliver reliably?
If she learns marketing and the price is wrong, the real problem remains. This is why assumptions about the business need testing with customers, costs and delivery, not only with reflection. Personal development and business testing often need to happen together.
Decide, and be able to justify it
After diagnosis, you will probably find several possible areas to work on. Choose one for the next three months. You can use three questions: how much could it change my results, does it affect something I need soon, and can I make realistic progress with the time and support I have?
Then write your decision in one sentence that someone else could check. Compare “I want to communicate better” with “I will rewrite my CV to show what I contributed in each role, including projects and results where I can state them honestly, and ask two people to review it by Friday.” The second can be reviewed and adjusted. Never invent numbers to make it look stronger.
Being able to justify a decision is itself a professional skill. It shows that you considered evidence and alternatives. You may still be wrong, and that is acceptable if you review the result and learn from it.
Change one thing, then look again
Once you have chosen a gap, change one thing at a time where you can. If the graduate rewrites her CV and sends another batch of applications, she can compare the response with the first batch. If she also changes her target sector and her interview approach in the same week, she will not know which change mattered.
Be careful with conclusions. Results also depend on job fit and market conditions, such as how many people apply for the same roles, which you do not control. A small number of applications can only suggest a direction. Use it to decide what to try next, not to judge yourself.
Try this week
- Write the one belief about yourself that you act on most.
- List the evidence for it and at least two other possible explanations.
- Ask two people for specific feedback on it.
- Decide what you will do, by when, and what result would show it worked or did not.
Then repeat the review after three months. Your role, business and goals will change, and so will the question of what needs developing.
#CMA #Careers #hafezfarid #cmafasttrack
