
By: Dr Hafez Mohamed Farid Hamed
School of Business
International Academy of Engineering and Media Science, Egypt
hafez.mohammed.farid@iaems.edu.eg
Think of the last time someone told you your work was not clear enough, or not good enough. What did you do first? Explain, argue, withdraw, or ask a question?
How you respond in that moment has a large effect on what you learn. Feedback is information about a piece of work. It is not a verdict on you, and learning from it is a skill that can be practised.
Why feedback is hard to hear
Suppose a supervisor tells a graduate: “The analysis is solid, but I got lost in the middle.” She may hear only “I got lost” and conclude she is not good enough. (Hypothetical.)
Our work is part of who we are. When someone criticises it, it can feel personal even when it is not. Our minds are quick to look for threat, and we may argue, explain or withdraw before we have understood the point.
None of this is a weakness. It is a normal reaction. The question is what you do next.
Pause before you respond
When you receive difficult feedback, your first task is to listen. Do not defend yourself while the other person is speaking. Take notes if it helps. If you feel strongly, you can say: “Thank you, I would like to think about this and come back to you.”
Take a little time, a few hours or a day, before deciding what to do. Reactions often change once the first sting has passed.
Ask for specifics
General feedback such as “It needs work” or “It was not great” gives you little to act on. Ask clarifying questions in a curious tone:
“Which part lost you?”
“Can you give me an example?”
“What would you have liked to see instead?”
“What is the most important thing for me to change?”
The purpose is to understand, not to challenge. If the person cannot give an example, you might keep the comment in mind but give it less weight.
Separate three things
Feedback often mixes different elements. Try to separate them.
Facts: what actually happened or was observed. “The summary was on slide twelve.”
Interpretation: what the person made of it. “So I could not see your conclusion.”
Preference: what the person would like. “I prefer shorter slides.”
Facts are usually the easiest to use. Interpretation can be valuable, but it comes from the person’s own position. Preferences are worth listening to, especially if the person is your manager or client, but they may differ from others’ preferences.
Decide what to do with it
You do not have to act on every piece of feedback. Compare it with other sources: your own review, other people’s views, and the results you have seen. If three people say you speak too fast, that is a pattern worth taking seriously. But headcount is not the only test. The quality of the evidence and the consequence of the problem matter too. One person who reports a factual error, or says they cannot read your slides, may be telling you something important, since an error or an accessibility barrier can matter even when nobody else mentions it. Check it, and fix it if it is real. A single comment about a style preference is different: weigh it, and decide.
Choose one or two points to work on. Trying to fix everything at once can leave you changing nothing well. Write down the point, what you will do and when you will check it.
Thank the person, and follow up
A simple thank you encourages people to be honest again. You need not agree with everything to be grateful for the time and effort. Later, tell them what you changed: “After your comment, I moved the recommendation to the start. Does it work better?” This shows that you take feedback seriously and invites further input.
Handling unfair or unhelpful feedback
Not all feedback is useful. Some is vague, careless or biased. Some arrives in a harsh tone. You can still look for any detail that is helpful, while acknowledging that the delivery was poor.
If feedback is disrespectful or touches on matters unrelated to your work, you may need to raise it with the person or a manager. This is different from disliking criticism. Hard but fair feedback is valuable. Abusive feedback is not something you are required to accept.
Giving feedback to others
Your own experience can help you give better feedback. Be specific about what you saw, explain its effect, and suggest what might help. “In the meeting, you interrupted two colleagues. I think it made it harder for them to share ideas. Could you try waiting until they finish?” is clearer than “You are rude.”
Give it soon after the event, in private when it is critical, and include what worked well so that the person knows what to keep. Ask how they see it. They may know something you do not.
If you are a manager, be clear on standards. Kindness does not mean avoiding the truth. It means telling the truth in a way the person can use.
For founders
Customers give feedback in many forms: complaints, reviews, silence. Complaints are uncomfortable but can show where the business is failing. Silence is harder to read: customers who leave without comment may have had a similar problem. Ask a few of them politely why they left. Some will answer, and what they say may differ from what you assumed.
Take care not to build the whole business around one loud customer. Look for patterns across many.
A note to keep
Next time feedback comes, your first job is only to understand it. Listen, ask for one example, separate fact from interpretation and preference, and decide later what, if anything, to change. Then tell the person what you did.
Over time, people tend to notice who uses feedback, and that may affect how much honest feedback you receive.
#CMA #Careers #hafezfarid #cmafasttrack
